[Frage] Wall and Slab Openings


Is it possible to assign Wall Openings and/or Slab Openings to User Defined Architectural Elements?
I have tryied the same workflow as with normal Architectural Elements (Wall, Column, Slab, etc.) but I get the message: "Objects do not intersect components!"

Thank you in advance,
Csaba

Hi Csaba,

this isn´t possible. The functions create openings, recesses and so on.....in walls or slabs! And the UserDefinedArchitectureElement could be all........wall, slab, beam, column......

Best wishes
Michael

Michael Theuer
Customer Success Manager
Allplan GmbH

Hi Michael,

Thank you for your answer. I was hoping that someone comes with a solution.
I have tried to define a "minus" element that, without using the boolean functions for 3D elements, gets substracted automatically from my U-D element. For the moment, I was not able to create it. Have you got any idea if it is even possible or not?

Best,
Csaba

Hi Csaba,

I don´t see an opportunity without the boolean functions and with a similar comfortable way......Why you don´t like the Booleans?

Best wishes
Michael

Michael Theuer
Customer Success Manager
Allplan GmbH

Hello Michael,

I could define this "minus" element as construction line and place it freely in my model, eliminating this way the boolean operations.
Another functionality would be in case on cylinders: let's say, one of my elements has a circular whole in it. If I substract a cylinder from my object, it is time consuming to modify the whole's diameter afterwards. Using a "minus" object, I only need to scale it and the job would be done.

Best regards,
Csaba